November 20, 2026

Hicks Amendment set to be debated in the House of Lords today would give all families the right to correct the public record in court in future

11. Tributes from fans at Sarah and Vicki's final resting place

New amendment inspired by Jenni Hicks and Trevor Hicks’ fight for justice against South Yorkshire Police after losing their daughters in Hillsborough disaster

 

An amendment to the Hillsborough Law which has been inspired by the decades-long fight for justice by Jenni Hicks and Trevor Hicks, whose teenage daughters died in the 1989 disaster, is expected to be debated in the House of Lords this afternoon (21st Oct).

 

The proposal, Amendment 106, dubbed the Hicks Amendment, would give families and individuals who have been seriously misrepresented in court proceedings, as a result of a public authority’s failure to act with candour, the right to apply to a court to correct the public record.

 

The amendment has been tabled by Baroness Kennedy of the Shaws, Lord Alton of Liverpool, Lord Wills and Baroness May of Maidenhead as part of the passage of the Hillsborough Law.

 

Jenni and Trevor lost their teenage daughters, Sarah, 19, and Victoria, 15, in the 1989 Hillsborough disaster, in which 97 Liverpool supporters were unlawfully killed.
Jenni Hicks
Jenni Hicks said: “Trevor and I are very pleased that Parliament is now due to consider the Hicks Amendment, and we very much hope it will help other wronged families in future.

 

“We have spent years trying to put right something that should never have happened in the first place. It should not be this difficult for a family to correct the public record when there is a serious factual error.

 

“We cannot change what happened to Sarah and Vicki, but if something positive can come from our experience, and other families can be spared the same struggle, that would mean a great deal to us.”

 

Their campaign to secure a Statement in Open Court followed the refusal of South Yorkshire Police to correct the legal record, which wrongly states that Sarah and Vicki experienced “swift and sudden [deaths] as shown by the medical evidence.”

 

In the early 1990s, Jenni and Trevor brought a test case against South Yorkshire Police on behalf of their daughters’ estates, arguing that the girls had endured pain and suffering before death.

 

That case was rejected at every level, culminating in 1992 in a ruling by five Law Lords in the House of Lords – then the UK’s highest appellate court – on the basis that the girls were assumed to have been unconscious within 30 seconds and dead within minutes.

 

The “30-second rule” was relied upon in civil litigation following Hillsborough to argue that victims lost consciousness almost immediately and therefore didn’t suffer.

 

Subsequent inquiries – the Hillsborough Independent Panel (2012) and the fresh inquests (2014 – 2016) – have since shown that this assumption was fundamentally wrong, with medical experts concluding that many victims remained conscious for extended periods, experiencing fluctuating levels of awareness, distress and injury.

 

More than three decades later, their parents are still fighting to have the public record formally corrected.

 

The Hicks Amendment would establish a legal route for other families facing similar circumstances, where a court has found that a public authority failed to act with candour, transparency and frankness in proceedings and that this led to serious and adverse misrepresentation.
Trevor Hicks
Trevor Hicks said: “The Hillsborough Law is about making sure that public authorities are honest and accountable. But there also needs to be a way of putting things right when they have failed in that duty.

 

“We have had to fight for far too long to get the truth properly reflected in the court record. I am pleased that members of the House of Lords recognise that this is a problem which needs addressing in law and hopefully they will agree that the Hicks’ Amendment does just that.

 

“We are very grateful to Baroness Kennedy, Lord Alton, Lord Wills and Baroness May for their strong support for our campaign, and for bringing forward the Hicks Amendment. We hope that other members of the House of Lords and House of Commons will now support this simple but vitally important change.”

 

The family’s barrister, Caoilfhionn Gallagher KC, welcomed the amendment, stating: “The Hicks Amendment forming part of the Hillsborough Law would be an important step to addressing decades of injustice. This legislation was born out of the Hillsborough tragedy, and it is deeply troubling that, more than 37 years later, the consequences of what happened remain an open wound for families such as Jenni and Trevor Hicks.

 

“The Hillsborough Law must not simply impose duties on public authorities. It must also provide meaningful remedies when those duties are breached.

 

“This amendment would ensure that families who have suffered serious misrepresentation as a result of a public authority’s failure to act with candour in court have a clear course of action set down in law.

 

“But Jenni and Trevor should not have to wait for new legislation. In their case, the swiftest and most appropriate resolution remains the Statement in Open Court which they have sought for so long.

 

“After years of unnecessary delay, we are finally hopeful that a hearing to deliver that statement will take place in the very near future. That is the immediate priority for Jenni and Trevor, while this amendment offers the prospect of helping other families in the years ahead.”
Solicitor Nia Williams, Jenni Hicks, Chief Const Lauren Poultney, Trevor Hicks
Nia Williams, the family’s solicitor, also stressed that Jenni and Trevor’s own case should now be resolved without further delay.

 

She said: “The Hicks Amendment is an important step in the right direction. It recognises a serious gap in the law: where a public authority has failed in its duty of candour and caused serious harm through misrepresentation in court, those affected should have a clear legal route to correct the public record.

 

“In Jenni and Trevor’s own case, South Yorkshire Police have now agreed in principle to a Statement in Open Court. This should happen as quickly as possible. And the Hicks Amendment is a legacy for Sarah and Vicki, ensuring that other families do not need to wait and fight for so long to ensure the record is corrected.”

 

The proposed Amendment 106 would allow an affected person, their family member or representative to apply to the court for a statement correcting the record, provided the court has made the necessary findings about a public authority’s conduct. Any resulting statement would have to be delivered in open court.

 

The amendment is due to be considered as the Hillsborough Law continues its passage through Parliament.